Environment, Energy & Compute · Capstone brief

ENV-12 · Public comment draft

Write a public-comment style brief suitable for a local hearing, with citations and uncertainty called out.

The question

Write a public-comment style brief suitable for a local hearing, with citations and uncertainty called out.

Sources / materials

Prior briefs’ artifacts welcome. Hearing or docket context (real or mock) teacher-defined. Comment template with citation and uncertainty requirements. Public docs only.

Expected failure modes

Emotional speech with no citations. Certainty language where data are thin. Comment too long for a hearing record. Trespass anecdotes as evidence.

Done looks like

Comment ≤3 pages (or teacher word limit); citation list; uncertainty callouts inline; ask (what the body should do); oral 2-minute version.

Five C's

CT: hearing-ready honesty. CR: cited claims only. CO: peer times the oral version. CM: comment text. CZ: residents at the hearing.

Mentor role

Env or gov teacher reviews citation density and tone. School-supervised.

Rubric calibration

R1: one docket/context. R2: claims cited. R3: status quo named. R4: uncertainties inline. R5: oral version fits. R6: refuses trespass evidence.

Two ways this goes wrong

(a) Sermon, no sources. (b) Encyclopedia nobody will read into the record.

Credit lane fit

Lane A immediately, and a natural finale for this track. No verified credit claim.